Conversations For Transformation: Essays Inspired By The Ideas Of Werner Erhard

Conversations For Transformation

Essays By Laurence Platt

Inspired By The Ideas Of Werner Erhard

And More


GoFundMe

Give It All  Away

Napa, California, USA

June 21, 2024



"Life is empty and meaningless."
... Jean-Paul Sartre
Early on: "Life is empty and meaningless, and it's empty and meaningless that it's empty and meaningless."
... 
Later on: "You  are empty and meaningless, and it's empty and meaningless that you're empty and meaningless."
... 
"If you don't take it out into the world, you didn't get it in the first place."
... 
This essay, Give It All  Away, is the eighth in an octology fleshing out the distinction Empty And Meaningless: It is also the sequel to Give It Away.

I am indebted to Donovan Copley who inspired this conversation.




At the end of a guest event I led offering people the opportunity to experience Werner's work, a woman came up to me, introduced herself, and said "I'm a counselor too.". To me, her saying "too" implied she had me pegged as a counselor like her. I bit my lip, listening intently. My very first priority was for her to experience being heard / gotten. Clearing up the notion that Werner's work equates to counseling, could wait. "How great!" I said. And I meant it. "Who (or what) do you counsel?" I asked. "I counsel people who can't find meaning in their lives, I help them find meaning in their lives" she told me, sincerely.

Elsewhere in this body of work, "helping" is differentiated from "assisting". That said, you can't make up a formula out of this (and if you try to, you'll ruin it). Try this on for size: life has no meaning. It's empty and meaningless. And it's empty and meaningless that it's empty and meaningless. Making it mean something (in particular, making it mean something that it's empty and meaningless) just adds arrogance. People who say they can't find meaning in their lives, may have discovered something truly profound, albeit unknowingly / unwittingly (let's not say they've discovered something truly "meaningful"):  that life has no meaning. Look: why spoil a good thing by adding meaning when they've already discovered there's none? Adding mud doesn't clarify the pond.

That's a graduate conversation. A guest event is not a graduate conversation. It's an introductory conversation by  graduates for non-graduates. Graduate conversations will come later. Even in introductory conversations, what's worth asking is: what's left when you give up adding meaning, in a futile attempt to make meaning where there's none? What's left when you give away whatever you've added, to make meaning out of that which really has no meaning?

One possible discovery from the inquiry "What's left when I give away whatever I've added, to make meaning out of that which really has no meaning?" is: authenticity. Life has no meaning, so when I give away whatever I've added, to make meaning out of that which really has no meaning, what's left is who I really am ie as my authentic Self, the meaningless me  (if you will). Another possible discovery from the inquiry "What's left when I give away whatever I've added, to make meaning out of that which really has no meaning?" is: context, just pure context, the space in which life and the events of my life show up. Make no error: confronting pure context can be daunting - at least at first. But if that is what's there, then making meaning out of that which really has no meaning, may just be a robotic defense mechanism against confronting the dauntingness of pure context ie against confronting who we really  are. Maybe.

And yet one more possible discovery from the inquiry "What's left when I give away whatever I've added, to make meaning out of that which really has no meaning?" is: compassion - compassion for the very human state of affairs when life (ie meaningless  life) isn't experienced as enough, and thus we pile on made-up meaning in the futile hope that some day it will be enough (life is enough when we create it as enough without muddying it by adding meaning).

That explains why I don't consider myself a counselor (she got it). It also explains why I'm willing to give away the meaning I've added, to make meaning out of that which really has no meaning. Once you've done that, what's left to do is to have a great life. Share it with people. Give it away. Give it all  away.



Communication Promise E-Mail | Home

© Laurence Platt - 2024 Permission