Conversations For Transformation: Essays Inspired By The Ideas Of Werner Erhard

Conversations For Transformation

Essays By Laurence Platt

Inspired By The Ideas Of Werner Erhard

And More


GoFundMe

Distinctions Are Secondary

Cowboy Cottage, East Napa, California, USA

July 15, 2023

"If you don't take it out into the world, you didn't get it in the first place." ... 
This essay, Distinctions Are Secondary, is the companion piece to Half-Life.

It is also the sequel to Free To Be And Free To Act.

I am indebted to Mark Spirtos who inspired this conversation.




What we say and talk about when we're catalyzing transformation ie the distinctions we leverage in the process of bringing it forth, is really only secondary to the space that creates for us to be transformed ie the space that leaves us with ie the space that leaves us in. The distinctions of transformation, while critical in galvanizing the experience of being transformed and bringing it to front and center stage, then become secondary once we're free to be and free to act. In this way, distinguishing the distinctions of transformation is a means to an end: the end is being transformed ie being free to be and free to act.
Werner is wont to say that "Creation is a matter of distinction.". I recommend you listen him speaking that - intently, clearly, rigorously. By it, he brilliantly distinguishes the way we create. We create by distinguishing something. Once we've distinguished it, once it's brought forth out of nothing, it's created. And look: if it's not brought forth out of nothing, then something's not been created, rather something's been merely changed. Bringing forth / creating being transformed, is like that too, except what's being distinguished is an experience rather than a sculpture or a painting or a poem ie rather than a hard copy.

In regard to my assertion that distinguishing the distinctions of transformation is a means to an end (the end is being transformed ie being free to be and free to act), distinctions are like transformation's chisels, its brushes, its pens. And just as in a studio for sculptures, paintings, and poems, in the end we're left with something brought forth ie something created: the experience of being transformed. And at that point the chisels, brushes, and pens which were deployed during the creation of / during the set-up  of the experience of being transformed, will become secondary (note: not irrelevant  - just secondary).

It's of marginal interest to the artist that we admire and appreciate her chisels, brushes, and pens. What's paramount to her ie the whole impression of her creation, is the experience we have of whatever artwork it is she creates using them. They, like the distinctions of transformation, while crucial in setting up the experience of being transformed, become secondary once the artwork / experience is fully created. When the experience of being transformed is fully gotten, we're free to be and free to act. That's the miracle  of the work of transformation! So the end doesn't justify  the means as much as it's set up by it.

There's no more sorry a life than the life of a smart aleck Mr know-it-all  who's got all the distinctions of transformation down cold, and yet whose life is patently unfulfilled, who's not free to be and free to act. Don't fall into that trap (and oh my: isn't that a really easy trap to fall into?). The distinctions, while critical to catalyzing / setting up the experience of being transformed, will become secondary once it comes to actually living a life free to be and free to act.
Werner is also wont to say that once you realize you really don't know anything ie once you realize you know nothing  ie once you realize you only know what you know in order to survive, a portal opens. And in that moment you will get to know the material (ie all  material) in an entirely new way. That's the moment of transformation. And the work of transformation provides the distinctions which open that portal and accelerate that moment. Just don't deploy the distinctions of transformation to be clever, to impress people, or to look good. Don't intellectualize. Be free to be. Act. It's simple: just be a human being.



Communication Promise E-Mail | Home

© Laurence Platt - 2023 Permission