Conversations For Transformation: Essays Inspired By The Ideas Of Werner Erhard

Conversations For Transformation

Essays By Laurence Platt

Inspired By The Ideas Of Werner Erhard

And More


GoFundMe

Doing The Being:

A Well Lived Life

Novato, California, USA

March 14, 2026



This essay, Doing The Being: A Well Lived Life, is the third in the open second group People (click here for the complete first group of thirty five People): I am indebted to Charles "Raz" Ingrasci who inspired this conversation, and to Jack Rafferty who contributed material.



What can we say about a great man, about a really  great man? Not enough? Too much? There's lots to say. For starters, here's one episode that says it all.
Werner is speaking from a podium, with an audience of hundreds  of people. We call these events "Be With"s - secondarily, because they are occasions to be with people listening for transformation; primarily, because they are opportunities to be with  Werner. And while he's speaking with us from the podium, he's looking through his materials which are in a manila folder, searching for something to illustrate what he's distinguishing, but not finding it. Eventually he stops speaking. The auditorium is pin-drop silent. All we're hearing through his wireless microphone is the sound of the rustling of papers, and nothing.

Suddenly he calls out "Raz" (what's a raz?  I wonder ...). Nothing. Still pin-drop silence. So he calls out again, louder and more urgently this time "RAZ!". A silent minute ticks by. And then, in that silence, behind me and over to my right, I hear a door opening. I turn around to see a medium built man standing framed in the doorway, back-lit by the lights of the lobby - it's Raz, evidently. He exchanges a few words with Werner who then finds what he's looking for in the manila folder. Then Raz turns around and leaves. The door closes behind him and the Be With continues, with Werner being his brilliant Self as usual.

From that moment on, that's who Raz was for me: he was that guy who knew all the stuff Werner needed, and where it was. He was that guy with Werner people looked to for the important things, the final seemingly insignificant yet hugely powerful items that make well lived lives coming from transformation accessible. That's who Raz was for me for the next 45 years or so. Whenever I heard "Raz ... RAZ!", I knew: as long as Raz was there, we'd all be alright.



On Taking Enlightenment To India

Werner, at Raz's behest, traveled to India, and met many important people there, including Prime Minister Morarji Ranchhodji Desai and major spiritual leaders, all of which led to the inevitable offering of Werner's work in India. Man! I thought to myself, you have to have some balls  to take enlightenment  to India!  So I wrote an essay about what transpired which I titled On Taking Enlightenment To India. I shared it with Raz who surprised me by saying he didn't like it! And I, rapidly becoming very defensive, asked him why he didn't like it, to which he bristled "Because that's not how it actually happened!".

Now I pride myself in being open and coachable, although (to be honest) I didn't like it that he didn't like it  one iota. Nevertheless we arranged to meet so that he could share his opinion  (or so I called it) of what happened, with me. He began speaking. An hour and a half later, he reached the first comma in the opening sentence of his description. It was all I could do to keep up with him, scribbling notes furiously in my notepad. I then rewrote the essay which now includes all his brilliant, genius contributions. It's arguably one of my best works to date. It's certainly one of my best known, having been cited as a reference deserving of a front-and-center  spot in the historic annals of what actually happened which culminated in Werner taking enlightenment to India.



The Oprah Winfrey Interview



Raz gave an utterly memorable nearly one hour interview to Oprah Winfrey in which he laid bare his current work. Of that hour, all of which I thought was fabulous, there was one minute which took my breath away. In it he shared with Oprah that he had taught his father how to cry. I was rendered literally breathless. Teaching his father to cry? Isn't that as extraordinary (if not more so) as taking enlightenment to India? The rest of the interview was just as brilliant, genius. But that one minute teaching-his-father-to-cry segment opened up something in my heart which I hope will never be closed again, ever.


The Apple Doesn't Fall Far From The Tree



And then ... there's his family, and the thing I want you to get most about his family is that after God made Raz's family (which is to say after Raz made the family that God made), he broke the mold. Raz for his wife, and she for him, were the love of each others' lives for almost 50 years. Their children have a direct access to transformation which defies their youthful years, displaying an uncanny (and totally natural) ability to "lead with love". The apple doesn't fall far from the tree, and the proof of the pudding (ie the apple pie) is in the eating. Their lives are lived from transformation. The mixture is disconcerting.


Doing The Being



Transformation / enlightenment is said to be living coming from the being, bringing it to bear on everyday living. What Raz's life epitomizes for me, is not merely bringing  the being to bear, but doing  the being. It's a way that's prudent, pragmatic, practical. Doing the being, his life epitomizes a life well lived.



Communication Promise E-Mail | Home

© Laurence Platt - 2026 Permission