Conversations For Transformation: Essays Inspired By The Ideas Of Werner Erhard

Conversations For Transformation

Essays By Laurence Platt

Inspired By The Ideas Of Werner Erhard

And More


GoFundMe

What We Forgot

Carmel By The Sea, California, USA

June 11, 2025



"There is no necessary relationship between the way you feel, the way you think, the way you are, the way you figured it out, and the way it really is."
... 
"Understanding is the booby prize."
... 
"Why am I so shy?"
... The Beatles, It's Only Love
This essay, What We Forgot, is the companion piece to Werner Erhard Quote Experience.




Prior to the onset of transformation in our lives (or maybe I should say prior to the onset of the miracle  of transformation in our lives), the way we would have begun an inquiry into the areas of our lives that weren't working, would have been to ask "Why ...?" questions. We are  that "Why ...?" questions (ie looking for reasons why our lives are the way they are) will somehow bring back our power to have them work in the areas where they aren't working now.

There are two parts to any "Why ...?" question: 1) the inquiry "Why ...?", and 2) the answer "Because ...". We are that every "Why ...?" inquiry goeswith  (as Alan Watts may have said) a "Because ..." answer. And we are that when we figure out what the "Because ..." answer is, we'll regain the power to have our lives work again in areas where they aren't working, or in areas which once worked and are now no longer working (and of course, every "Why ...?" question may have more than  one answer ie may have more than one "Because ..." - but that's a subject for another conversation on another occasion).

Q) "Why am I not happy?": A) "Because I don't have what I want.". Q) "Why do I have negative thoughts?": A) "Because I'm a sinner ie a bad person.". Q) "Why am I so shy?": A) "Because I was once hurt by that little red-haired girl I loved.". Q) "Why doesn't life give me nice things (and it should) because I'm such a good guy?": A) "I don't know why ... but if I keep asking, I'll eventually find out why, and then  I'll be happy. When I know why, I'll be happy.".

Now look: all these inquiries / examples assume there's a necessary or causal relationship between the way we feel, the way we think, the way we are, the way we figured it out, and the way it really is. We assume that what we'll get from "Why ...?" questions, is an understanding  of the relationship between them. In other words, we are that there's a necessary or causal relationship between the way we feel, the way we think, the way we are, the way we figured it out, and the way it really is, and if we could only understand that relationship, we'd regain the power to have our lives work again (it's a subtext).

But there isn't. There's no necessary relationship between them. Really there isn't. I want you to get that. There just isn't. Or at least I want you to try on it's just possible that there isn't. "Say whut?!  There isn't?". No, there isn't. None whatsoever. You just made up that there is. Then you forgot you made up that there is, and you started running your life as if  there is. Things haven't worked ever since / that's when things stopped working. There's no "Why ...?".

Now there's a trap to all of this, a trap that comes in various forms: "So then what's the point?", "So is this all there is?", "There must be something more!". But there is none, and yes, and no there isn't. The trouble with it is twofold: 1) it's that these answers don't fit into our structures ie they don't fit into our categories, and 2) isn't it that our instinctive response to finding ourselves in a trap is to try to figure out "Why ...?"  ie to revert to looking for the "Because ...", to try to get an understanding as if  that will make a difference ... which only tightens the jaws of the trap tighter? (that's another subtext right there).

Untangling yourself from the trap starts with observing the trap as if  it were real. See if you can bracket off the headlong rush for answers, to understand.



Communication Promise E-Mail | Home

© Laurence Platt - 2025 Permission