Conversations For Transformation: Essays Inspired By The Ideas Of Werner Erhard

Conversations For Transformation

Essays By Laurence Platt

Inspired By The Ideas Of Werner Erhard

And More


GoFundMe

Symbolic Substitution

Continuum Estate, Pritchard Hill Appellation, Napa Valley, California, USA

June 24, 2023



"Lots of people have talked about taking that step into the unknown. Taking that step into the unknown is actually a lot less courageous than taking a step from  the unknown."
... 
"At some point, safety is just pure waste. I mean, if you just want to be safe, don't get out of bed. Don't get in your car. Don't do anything."
... Stockton Rush, co-founder / CEO OceanGate, Titan submersible pilot

"We didn't start the fire, it was always burning since the world's been turning."
... Billy Joel




What are our lives? I mean, what is living really?

In the matter of what our lives really are ie in the matter of what living really is, we've substituted the symbols  of living, for living. With this cardinal error in effect, what our lives and living have come to be misconstrued as, is dealing with the circumstances around us. Our lives have become it ie dealing with the circumstances of our lives as symbols (more on this later) defines and measures what our lives are. That there's no end to the circumstances, is not what is under the microscope here. What's under the microscope here is we interchange dealing with the circumstances as symbols, with our lives / with living itself.

We've made winning  a symbol of purpose. We've made wealth  a symbol of self-worth. We've made opinionated righteousness  a symbol of integrity. We've made accumulating  and amassing, the symbols of fullness and being complete. We live our lives in symbolic substitution  mode (if you will) which leaves us regarding living as a kind of symbolic representation  in which dealing with and managing the symbols of the circumstances of our lives, comes to represent what our lives are ie in which dealing with and managing the symbols of the circumstances of our lives has come to represent what living is. So Q: What are our lives? What is living? A: Dealing with the circumstances as symbols. It's an unexamined axiom, one we've held as self-evident for years if not centuries.

Now, I have a question: how did we get this way ie when did we make this cardinal error of substituting the symbols of our lives, for our lives? When did we start living lives of symbolic representation in which dealing with and managing the symbols of our lives has come to represent what our lives actually are? Try this on for size (as one of a plethora of possible answers): we didn't "get this way", we didn't "make any cardinal error", we didn't "start living this way". No, it was none of the above. Rather, what if it were that we just inherited  being this way ie that we simply inherited living lives of symbolic substitution?

To be clear about what I'm saying here: circumstances are, and they must be dealt with and managed. Our lives and living are clearly never pretty when the circumstances aren't dealt with and managed ie when we ignore or neglect them. This isn't about that. This is about differentiating between what our lives really are ie what living really is, and dealing with the circumstances. Mostly we are  that dealing with and managing what the symbols of our circumstances represent, is our lives / is living. It's a costly way to be, an expensive  costly way to be, an inherited expensive costly way to be. The cost? It is authenticity.

I am transformed (it could be said) once I differentiate between living my real life, and my faux  life - which I consider to be dealing with / managing what the circumstances of my life as symbols, represent. Differentiating between my life, and dealing with / managing the circumstances of my life as symbols, allows me to differentiate between my life itself, and my faux life of substituting symbols for my life (dealing with the circumstances). Substituting symbols for my life in lieu of living my life itself, kills off my access to living authentically, leaving me living only by symbolic representation ie as the result of symbolic substitution. "I've amassed a lot (the symbol) so they'll think I'm whole and complete (the substitution)" etc, is the epitomy of living our lives inauthentically.



Communication Promise E-Mail | Home

© Laurence Platt - 2023 Permission